Customs clearance for international express delivery is the most common bottleneck in cross-border transportation. Failure not only leads to cargo detention and additional costs, but in serious cases, may also result in return or destruction. To effectively resolve the problem, you must first accurately identify the cause of the failure, then implement targeted countermeasures and implement preventive measures. The following provides practical solutions from three perspectives: “Cause Analysis – Emergency Solutions – Long-Term Avoidance.”
- Identify the Root Cause: The 3 Core Reasons for Customs Clearance Failure
Customs clearance failures are not accidental. They often stem from negligent preparation or unfamiliarity with destination policies. Common problems focus on three main categories: document discrepancies, improper declarations, and non-compliant goods. Different countries’ regulatory priorities directly affect the probability of failure (e.g., Europe’s strict VAT regulations, the US’s focus on intellectual property rights, and Australia’s strict controls on agricultural products).
- Missing or Incorrect Documents: The “Basic Threshold” of Customs Clearance
This is the most common reason for failure, accounting for over 60%. Core issues include: 1. Missing key documents, such as goods shipped to the EU lacking CE certification or certificates of origin, or commercial shipments lacking a formal commercial invoice; 2. Inconsistent document information, such as mismatches between the goods name, quantity, and value on the invoice and the actual contents, or incorrect recipient addresses and contact information, making it difficult for customs to verify the recipient’s identity; 3. Non-compliant document formats, such as invoices that fail to include the word “Commercial Invoice,” fail to include complete buyer and seller information, or translations that fail to meet local language requirements (e.g., Portuguese documents required for shipments to Brazil).
These seemingly basic issues are often overlooked by sellers or shippers simply because they’re too lazy to bother. For example, individuals may use handwritten lists instead of formal invoices when shipping, or e-commerce sellers may omit product certification documents to save costs, ultimately resulting in shipments being held up at customs.
- Improper Declaration: Triggering Customs “Key Inspections”
Oversights in the declaration process can easily lead to shipments being identified as “abnormally declared,” resulting in customs clearance delays or even return shipments. There are two main scenarios: under- or over-declaration. Under-declaration is often used to circumvent tariffs (e.g., declaring a $1,000 electronic product as $200), but the customs system will identify it as “declared value significantly different from market price,” triggering an immediate investigation. Over-declaration is often seen by individuals seeking to maximize compensation, but may be suspected of “smuggling” or “false declaration” due to its excessive scope. The second is vague declarations, such as declaring “mobile phone accessories” as “electronic products” or failing to specify the material (e.g., batteries, liquids) or intended use (e.g., medical/civilian). This prevents customs from determining the nature of the goods, requiring additional information from the sender, thus lengthening customs clearance times. Even more serious is the omission of key information, such as failing to declare the presence of hazardous materials (e.g., lithium batteries not marked with UN3480) or failing to specify whether the goods are branded (e.g., counterfeit goods not declared), directly triggering customs inspections.
- Non-compliant Goods: Crossing the Destination’s “Prohibition and Restriction Red Line”
Different countries have clear prohibitions and restrictions on inbound goods. If the goods themselves do not meet these requirements, customs clearance failure is almost certain. Common scenarios include: First, violations of embargo regulations. For example, meat products shipped to the US or fresh fruit shipped to Australia are directly detained due to biosafety concerns. Second, failure to meet product compliance standards. For example, electronic products for the European market lack CE certification, children’s toys do not meet the EN 71 standard, or medical devices for the US market lack FDA certification. Third, intellectual property rights issues. For example, shipping unauthorized branded products (such as unauthorized Nike shoes or Apple accessories) can be detained by customs due to infringement, even if the declaration is true. Fourth, shipments exceeding personal use. For example, a personal shipment containing dozens of identical items is classified by customs as “commercial use” but is not declared according to the commercial shipment process, resulting in customs clearance delays.
II. Emergency Response: 4 Steps to Quickly Resolve Customs Clearance Issues
Once you receive a customs clearance failure notification (usually from a courier or freight forwarder), you must respond quickly within 3-7 days (some countries will destroy the goods if the deadline is exceeded). Follow the four-step process of “checking the notification – submitting supporting documents – discussing solutions – monitoring progress” to minimize losses.
- Obtain a “Customs Clearance Failure Notice” as soon as possible to clarify the specific reason.
First, contact the customs clearance entity (official couriers such as DHL/FedEx will contact customs directly, while freight forwarders must use their partner customs clearance agency) and request a formal “Customs Clearance Failure Notice” issued by customs. This document will clearly indicate the reason for the failure, such as “lack of CE certification,” “abnormal declared value,” or “goods prohibited.” Avoid blindly handling the matter based on vague information.
For example, if the notification indicates “Declared Value Discrepancies with Actual Value of Goods,” further confirmation of the “reasonable value range” determined by customs is required. If “Certificate of Origin Missing,” the solution of “reissue of documents + explanatory letter” must be clarified. Never blindly request “re-clearance” or “return shipment” without clarifying the reason, as this will incur additional costs (such as second customs clearance fees and storage fees).
- Targeted Supplemental Documents Ensure “First-Time Success”
According to the reason for failure, quickly prepare and supplement the required documents. The core principles are “authenticity, completeness, and compliance” to avoid a second failure due to non-compliant documents.
If the documents are missing/incorrect: You must complete the documents as required by customs. For example, if a commercial invoice is missing, a new official invoice must be produced that includes “buyer and seller information, goods name (in Chinese and English), quantity, unit price, total price, payment method, and place of origin.” If the address is incorrect, provide the recipient’s identification (such as a passport or driver’s license) and issue a “Letter of Address Correction” to be submitted to customs by the courier. If the translation is inconsistent, find a local recognized translation agency to retranslate and stamp it.
If the declaration is improper: If the value is understated, you must resubmit a true invoice and attach a “Letter of Circumstances” (explaining the reason for the understatement, such as “personal mailing is unfamiliar with declaration rules”) and prepare funds to pay the additional customs duties. If the declaration is vague, provide a “Detailed Description of Goods” to specify the material, purpose, model, etc. (e.g., refining “electronic products” to “mobile phone charger, made of ABS plastic + copper, input voltage 100-240V”). If any information is omitted, you must submit a “Supplementary Declaration Form” and provide relevant certification (e.g., for goods containing batteries, a battery test report is required).
If the goods are non-compliant: First, determine if there’s room for remedy. For example, if a product hasn’t passed certification, expedited certification can be processed if time permits (for example, EU CE certification takes approximately 3-5 days). If the product is a prohibited or infringing product, remedy is almost impossible, and a decision to return or abandon the shipment must be made quickly to avoid incurring high storage fees (in some countries, daily storage fees can reach 1%-3% of the goods’ value).
- Negotiate a plan with the customs clearance provider, balancing cost and timeliness.
After supplementing the documents, negotiate a specific customs clearance plan with the courier or customs broker. The optimal solution will be selected based on the value and urgency of the goods. There are three common options:
Secondary customs clearance: This applies to situations where supplementary materials are available and the goods are compliant (e.g., missing documents or improper declaration). A secondary customs clearance fee (usually 1.5-2 times the initial clearance fee) is required, but the goods can be kept safe. This option is suitable for high-value goods (such as electronics and medical devices). For example, a lamp shipped to Germany that lacked CE certification could undergo secondary customs clearance after obtaining additional certification. Although this cost an additional €500 in customs clearance fees, it avoided the €10,000 loss of returning the goods.
Return Processing: If the goods cannot pass secondary customs clearance (e.g., for prohibited or infringing goods), or if the secondary customs clearance costs are too high, a return can be an option. Please note that return shipping not only incurs the return shipping fee (usually 80%-100% of the original shipping fee), but also requires the storage and inspection fees associated with customs clearance failure. Furthermore, some goods (e.g., prohibited goods) may face re-inspection by domestic customs upon return to China, so it is important to communicate this with the domestic customs clearance agency in advance.
Abandonment of Goods: For low-value goods with high return costs (e.g., low-value daily necessities or samples), you can apply to customs to “abandon the goods” to avoid subsequent costs. However, you need to confirm whether customs will accept the “abandonment application” and whether a destruction fee will be required (some countries require a small destruction fee of approximately $50-200). 4. Track progress throughout the process to avoid information gaps
After submitting your documents and finalizing your plan, you need to monitor customs clearance progress daily. You can check the status of your customs clearance on the courier’s website (e.g., DHL’s “Clearance in Progress” or “Clearance Completed”), or ask the customs broker for the contact information of your customs contact. This allows for prompt response should any new issues arise (e.g., customs requesting additional documentation).
For example, if your shipment fails customs clearance at Dutch customs due to an “ambiguous declaration,” after providing the additional documentation, you need to confirm that the customs broker has submitted the documents to Dutch customs and that they have accepted them. This helps prevent delays in submitting your application and potentially missing the processing deadline.
III. Long-Term Avoidance: 3 Tips to Reduce the Probability of Customs Clearance Failures
The fundamental solution to customs clearance failures is to take preventative measures before shipping. Frequent shippers, especially businesses or e-commerce sellers, should establish a standardized shipping process:
- Check Policies Before Shipping: Identify the destination’s prohibited and restricted shipments and compliance requirements.
Customs clearance regulations vary significantly between countries, so it’s important to confirm requirements through official channels before shipping. For example, for shipments to the EU, visit the EU Customs website to check the “CE Certification Scope” and “VAT Reporting Requirements.” For shipments to the US, verify the import standards for medical devices and food on the FDA website. Individuals can directly contact the courier company (such as DHL Customer Service). For corporate shipments, it’s recommended to work with a professional customs broker and obtain the “Destination Customs Clearance Guide.”
For example, for shipments to Australia, it’s important to confirm in advance whether the shipment contains wood products or agricultural products (such shipments require a quarantine certificate). For commercial shipments to Brazil, it’s important to confirm whether the recipient has a tax identification number (CNPJ/CPF). Shipments without a tax identification number are virtually impossible to clear.
- “Be Accurate” in Declarations: Avoid “Fuzziness” and “Arbitrariness”
When declaring, ensure “three accuracy” criteria: First, accurate value. Refer to the actual purchase price or market retail price of the goods to avoid under- or over-invoicing (generally, the declared value should not deviate from the market price by more than 20% to reduce the likelihood of verification); second, accurate content. The goods must be named specifically (e.g., “pure cotton T-shirt” rather than “clothing”), the material and intended use must be clear (e.g., “plastic children’s toys, suitable for children over 3 years old”), and any special ingredients must be clearly indicated (e.g., “contains lithium battery, capacity 1000mAh”); third, accurate quantity. The declared quantity must exactly match the quantity in the package to avoid over-declaring and under-delivering, or under-declaring and over-delivering.
E-commerce sellers can establish a “product declaration database” to pre-enter the declared name, value, material, and certification information for each SKU, allowing for direct access during shipment to reduce human error. Individual shipments should carefully check the list to avoid omitting key information out of fear of trouble.
- “Complete” Document Preparation: Checklist-Based Documents
Before shipping, prepare documents according to the destination’s requirements and the courier’s standards. It’s recommended to create a “document checklist” and check each one individually: Commercial shipments require a commercial invoice, packing list, certificate of origin (if required), and product certifications (such as CE, FDA); personal shipments require a pro forma invoice and a copy of the recipient’s ID (if required); special cargo (such as dangerous goods and medical devices) requires additional documentation such as a dangerous goods identification report and medical registration certificate.
For example, for electronics shipped to Europe, the document checklist should include: ① a formal invoice marked “Commercial Invoice” (including VAT number); ② the product’s CE certification; ③ a packing list (specifying the contents of each package); and ④ a certificate of origin (if tariff concessions are required). Verifying all documents correctly before shipping can significantly reduce customs clearance failures due to document issues.
In short, international express customs clearance failures are not an unsolvable problem. The key lies in quickly identifying the cause, accurately supplementing documentation, and promptly negotiating solutions. Furthermore, through proactive policy research, accurate declarations, and complete spare parts, risks can be mitigated at the source. For businesses, establishing standardized customs clearance processes and connecting with professional customs clearance resources are key measures to improve cross-border logistics efficiency and reduce losses.
If you have any international logistics service needs, please contact us by clicking the floating chat icon in the lower right corner or using the other contact information in the lower right corner of the page.
