When choosing between all risks, FPA, and WPA for marine cargo insurance, the key is to “match cargo risks and control premium costs.” There’s no absolute “best deal,” but rather “best fit.” It’s important to first understand the differences in coverage among the three, then consider factors such as cargo characteristics, transportation scenarios, and trade terms.
In this article, Weefreight will provide a detailed analysis, which we hope will be helpful.
Step 1: Understand the Core Coverage of the Three Major Insurance Types (Avoid Blind Purchases).
The foundation of marine cargo insurance is FPA. WPA is an extension of FPA, and all risks is a further extension of WPA. Coverage increases in a step-by-step manner, and premiums rise accordingly.
- Free from Particular Average (FPA): Basic protection, covering only “major accidents”
FPA has the narrowest coverage, focusing on “total loss or major partial loss caused by force majeure.” It only covers the following scenarios:
Natural disasters (such as typhoons, tsunamis, and earthquakes) resulting in total loss of cargo, or partial loss accompanied by an accident such as a grounding, run-aground, sinking, or incineration of the vessel;
Total or partial loss of cargo due to an accident (such as a collision, run-aground, grounding, or explosion);
Total or partial loss of cargo during loading, unloading, or transshipment (subject to specific scenarios such as the dropping of an entire cargo);
Sacrificial, contribution, and salvage expenses in general average (such as compensation for intentionally abandoning part of the cargo to avoid total loss of the vessel).
Note: FPA does not cover “partial loss” caused solely by natural disasters (such as a rainstorm soaking half a container of cargo).
- Water Damage Insurance (WA/WPA): FPA + “Partial Loss Due to Natural Disasters”
WPA coverage equals the full coverage of FPA + partial loss of cargo caused solely by natural disasters.
For example, if a ship is caught in a rainstorm during transit, causing 10 containers of cargo to become damp and damaged (not a total loss), FPA will not cover the loss, but WPA will. If the cargo were to sink due to a run-aside accident, WPA would cover both total and partial loss.
Note: “Water damage” in “WPA” does not refer to “all water damage,” but only to “water damage caused by natural disasters or accidents.” WPA does not cover losses caused by non-natural disasters/accidents, such as damaged packaging or freshwater exposure (e.g., freshwater leaks in the ship’s hold).
- All Risks (AR): WPA + General External Perils
All Risks is the most comprehensive insurance policy, covering the full coverage of WPA plus cargo losses caused by general external risks.
General external risks refer to losses during transportation caused by external factors other than natural disasters or accidents. Common scenarios include:
Theft and delayed delivery (cargo theft or loss);
Freshwater exposure (e.g., a ruptured freshwater pipe in a ship’s hold soaking the cargo);
Shortage (cargo quantity shortage, such as leakage caused by damaged packaging);
Mixed or contaminated (cargo contaminated by other impurities, such as grain mixed with dirt);
Leakage, collision, breakage, and hook damage (e.g., glassware shattered by collision);
Moisture and heat (e.g., cargo deterioration caused by high temperatures); and odor transfer (e.g., tea tainted by perfume).
Note: All Risks does not guarantee coverage for all risks. Exclusions apply, such as war, strikes, nuclear contamination, cargo defects (e.g., natural loss of perishable goods), and improper packaging by the shipper. To cover these risks, additional “special risks” (e.g., war risk, strike risk) are required.
Step 2: Select insurance based on the “cargo + scenario” to achieve optimal value (optimum fit).
The key principle behind this selection is: “For low-risk cargo/scenario, choose low-premium insurance (FPA), and for high-risk cargo/scenario, choose high-protection insurance (all risks)” to avoid “over-insurance and waste of premiums” or “under-insurance and losses.”
- Choosing “P&F Insurance” (lowest premium, suitable for low-risk)
If any of the following conditions are met, prioritize P&F insurance to reduce premium costs:
The cargo itself is highly resistant to risk: Examples include steel, ore, coal, and large machinery and equipment (which are less susceptible to damage from natural disasters or minor collisions, and are often valued only after total loss);
Safe transportation routes: Examples include short-distance ocean transport (such as routes between China, Japan, and South Korea), and routes not located in areas prone to natural disasters such as typhoons and tsunamis;
Cargo has been provided with additional protection: Examples include extremely sturdy packaging (such as sealed metal boxes), or the shipper has purchased additional insurance (such as domestic transportation insurance that covers partial risks);
Trade terms: If the buyer only requires “basic protection,” and both parties clearly agree to bear a portion of the losses themselves (this must be stated in the contract).
- Scenario for choosing “Water Damage Insurance” (medium premium, suitable for medium risk)
When cargo is “susceptible to partial loss due to natural disasters” but not susceptible to “general external risks,” choosing Water Damage Insurance is the most cost-effective option:
Cargo characteristics: Examples include bulk grain (wheat, corn), bulk ore (which is susceptible to partial mold and mildew due to heavy rain), and containerized non-precision industrial products (such as ordinary plastics, which are not susceptible to theft or breakage but may be damaged by water ingress due to natural disasters);
Transport scenarios: Examples include long-distance transoceanic routes (e.g., from China to Europe and the United States), routes through typhoon belts (e.g., the Northwest Pacific route), and monsoon regions (e.g., the Indian Ocean route). These routes present a higher risk of natural disasters but are not subject to risks of theft or shortages.
- Scenario for Choosing “All Risks” (Highest Premium, Suitable for High-Risk)
All Risks are essential in the following scenarios to avoid significant losses (premium costs are far lower than the risk of cargo loss):
Goods of high value and vulnerable to damage/theft: e.g., electronic products (cell phones and computers, prone to theft and damage from collisions), precision instruments (e.g., medical equipment, rendered useless if exposed to moisture/damage);
Goods susceptible to “general external risks”: e.g., food (biscuits and milk powder, prone to moisture, odor transfer, and shortages); clothing (prone to theft, mold from freshwater and rain); cosmetics (prone to leakage and deterioration from high temperatures); glassware/ceramics (prone to breakage);
Complex transportation: e.g., frequent transit (e.g., goods needing to transit through two or three ports, frequent loading and unloading, high risk of shortages and damage); poor security at the destination port (higher risk of theft);
Trade terms: For example, banks often require “all risks insurance” for letter of credit (L/C) payment methods. To ensure financial security; or the buyer explicitly requires high coverage (this must be stipulated in the contract).
Step 3: Additional Pitfall Avoidance Tips to Ensure a More Effective Deal
Clarify the “Insurance Amount” to Avoid Underinsurance or Overinsurance
The insurance amount is typically calculated as “the invoice value of the goods + 10% (expected profit)” (i.e., 110% of the CIF price). Too low an insurance amount may result in incomplete compensation for losses, while too high an amount may result in overpayment (the insurance company will pay based on actual losses, not exceeding the insured amount). For example, if the invoice value is $100,000, the recommended insurance amount is $110,000 (100,000 x 1.1).
Preferably choose well-known insurance companies to avoid claims disputes.
Choose leading domestic companies such as PICC, Ping An Insurance, and Pacific Insurance, or internationally renowned P&I clubs (such as the P&I Club). They have extensive network locations and standardized claims processes, avoiding claims denials or delays caused by smaller insurance companies with limited resources.
Carefully review the “Exclusions” and add additional insurance if necessary.
For risks not covered by all-risk policies, such as war, strikes, and defects in the goods, if the shipping route passes through war-torn areas (such as the Middle East or the Red Sea), additional “War Risk + Strike Insurance” is required. For perishable goods (such as fruit), confirm whether “Refrigeration Insurance” is covered (some all-risk policies do not include this and require additional coverage).
Retain the “Insurance Certificate + Cargo Evidence” to ensure a smooth claim settlement.
After purchasing insurance, retain the “Insurance Policy,” “Bill of Lading,” “Commercial Invoice,” and “Packing List.” If the goods are damaged, immediately take photos and videos, contact the insurance company for inspection, and request a “Cargo Damage Certificate” from the carrier to avoid claim failure due to insufficient evidence.
In summary, the key to “cost-effectiveness” lies in “precise matching.”
Low risk (damage-resistant cargo + safe shipping routes) → Choose FPA (saving premiums);
Medium risk (afraid of partial loss from natural disasters, but not afraid of general external risks) → Choose WPA (balancing cost and coverage);
High risk (vulnerable/susceptible cargo + complex transportation) → Choose All Risks (avoiding major losses).
Ultimately, “cost-effectiveness” in insurance isn’t about the lowest premium, but rather “covering all core risks at an acceptable cost” to avoid significant losses.
If you have any international logistics service needs, please contact us by clicking the floating chat icon in the lower right corner or using other contact information in the lower right corner.
