There’s no absolute advantage or disadvantage between “multi-warehouse shipping” and “single-warehouse stocking” in Amazon FBA. The key is to choose the appropriate inventory layout strategy based on the product stage, sales volume, cost structure, and operational objectives. The fundamental difference between the two lies in the balance between risk diversification and cost control—single-warehouse shipping focuses on efficiency and cost, while multi-warehouse shipping emphasizes experience and risk resilience.
In this article, Weefreight will analyze the core logic, applicable scenarios, practical strategies, and advanced thinking.
First, Clarify the Core Difference: The Underlying Logic of Single-Warehouse and Multi-Warehouse Stocking
Single-warehouse stocking refers to centrally shipping all FBA inventory to a single fulfillment center (FC) assigned by the Amazon system. Amazon then allocates inventory across warehouses based on order distribution. Multi-warehouse shipping involves pre-deploying inventory to multiple regional FCs through compliant methods (such as overseas warehouse transit and AGL logistics programs), and fulfilling orders directly from the warehouse closest to the buyer. The core differences between the two lie in three dimensions:
Time and Experience: Multiple warehouses enable “local delivery,” typically within 1-2 days (e.g., a Western US warehouse shipping an order to California, and an Eastern US warehouse shipping an order to New York). A single warehouse, however, may experience longer delivery times due to cross-regional transfers (e.g., orders shipped to the Eastern US warehouse alone may take 3-5 days).
Cost Structure: A single warehouse has lower front-end logistics costs (bulk discounts available for centralized shipments) and simpler inventory management (only needing to monitor the purchase, sales, and inventory of a single warehouse). Multiple warehouses increase front-end distribution costs, overseas warehouse transit costs, and increase the difficulty of monitoring inventory turnover.
Risk and Resilience: A single warehouse carries the risk of a “single point of failure” (e.g., warehouse overflow, regional logistics delays, product removal), resulting in immediate stockouts. Multiple warehouses can disperse risk, allowing inventory from other warehouses to quickly replenish if a warehouse experiences an issue.
- Single-Warehouse Stocking: Suitable for “Cost-Prioritized, Initial Trial-and-Error” Scenarios
Single-warehouse stocking is Amazon’s default inventory layout. Essentially, it’s a “light-operation, cost-controlled” option. Its core advantage lies in reducing initial trial-and-error costs and operational complexity. It’s suitable for the following situations:
- Applicable Scenarios
New product cold launch: Sales are unstable and market demand is unproven. Centralizing stocking in a single warehouse avoids the “overstocked inventory in some warehouses, out-of-stock in others” caused by splitting inventory across multiple warehouses. It also allows for quick testing of market acceptance (such as click-through rate, conversion rate, and repurchase rate) using single-warehouse data.
Low-Price/Small-Weight Products: These products have limited profit margins (e.g., jewelry and stationery with a price tag under $10) and a high proportion of front-end costs. The bulk discounts offered by centralized shipping from a single warehouse can significantly reduce logistics costs. Furthermore, cross-regional differences in fulfillment times for small and light items have a minimal impact on the customer experience.
Long-tail products with smaller sales volumes: For long-tail products with monthly sales of less than 50 orders, a single warehouse can adequately meet demand. Having inventory in multiple warehouses will result in “low inventory in each warehouse, yet having to bear the storage fees of multiple warehouses,” which in turn increases costs.
Supplemental stocking for non-core markets: For example, sellers primarily targeting the US market may only make small replenishments in secondary markets like Canada and Mexico. Stocking in a single warehouse (e.g., centrally shipping from a California warehouse, then having Amazon transfer to Canada) can simplify management.
- Key Operational Points
Relying on Amazon’s “Automatic Transfer”: After stocking in a single warehouse, Amazon will transfer some inventory to other warehouses based on national order distribution (this is the default mode of the “Inventory Placement Service”). However, please note that transfers incur additional fees (typically $0.3-$1/unit), which must be factored into profit calculations.
Keep a close eye on your “safety stock line”: If a single warehouse doesn’t have backup inventory, you must strictly calculate your replenishment cycle (first-leg transit time + customs clearance time + Amazon warehousing time). Typically, you reserve a safety stock of “30 days of sales volume + a 15-day buffer” to avoid stockouts.
Prioritize “logistics hub warehouses”: If you can obtain a designated warehouse from a logistics provider (which must meet Amazon’s requirements), prioritize hub warehouses with fast first-leg transit times and high transfer efficiency (such as ONT8 and LAX9 in the US, or FBA8 in Europe), which indirectly shortens national fulfillment times.
- Multi-Warehouse Shipping: Suitable for “Experience First, Scale and Expand” Scenarios
Multi-warehouse deployment is a proactive strategy to enhance market share. Its core goal is to capture traffic through “nearby fulfillment” (Amazon’s algorithm tends to favor listings with faster delivery times), reduce negative review rates, and mitigate operational risks. It is suitable for the following scenarios:
- Applicable Scenarios
Hot-selling/High-Volume Products: For hot-selling products with hundreds or even thousands of orders per month, a single warehouse cannot meet nationwide demand. A multi-warehouse deployment can avoid negative reviews caused by poor delivery times in remote areas and handle larger order volumes (such as during peak Black Friday and Cyber Monday).
High-Ticket/Heavy Goods: Heavy goods like furniture and appliances face extremely high cross-regional delivery fees (delivery fees for heavy goods within the US can reach over $20 per order). A multi-warehouse deployment can significantly reduce final-mile delivery costs. Buyers of high-ticket products are highly sensitive to delivery times, and next-day delivery can improve conversion rates.
Deeply Operate in Core Markets: For example, if you’re deeply engaged in the US market, you can stock inventory in the West (California), Central (Texas), and East (New York) to cover the three core consumer regions. For deeper engagement in the European market, you can establish warehouses in the UK, Germany, and France to avoid cross-regional customs clearance delays after Brexit.
Peak Season Risk Mitigation Needs: During peak seasons (such as Q4), a single warehouse is prone to overstocking and delayed warehousing. Multiple warehouses can help distribute inventory. If one warehouse is slow to receive warehousing, others can ship goods as normal, avoiding stockouts during peak season.
- Key Operational Points
Compliance with “Multi-Warehouse Distribution”: Amazon does not allow direct shipments to multiple warehouses. This can be achieved through two methods:
Overseas Warehouse Transshipment: First, bulk shipments are sent to a third-party overseas warehouse in the target country. Then, they are distributed to multiple FBA warehouses based on sales forecasts (pay attention to labeling and warehousing compliance at the overseas warehouses);
Amazon AGL Logistics: Through Amazon’s official AGL (Advanced Global Logistics) system, the system automatically distributes goods to multiple FBA warehouses based on sales data, eliminating manual operation by the seller. Allocate inventory based on sales data: The core of multi-warehouse stocking is precise distribution. First, analyze the regional distribution of orders over the past 3-6 months (view this in Amazon’s Business Reports → Sales and Traffic). Allocate inventory proportionally: For example, if orders in the Western US account for 50%, the Eastern US accounts for 30%, and the Central US accounts for 20%, then the corresponding warehouse inventory should be allocated in a 5:3:2 ratio to avoid regional inventory imbalances.
Control multi-warehouse management costs: Calculate the turnover rate for each FBA warehouse individually, and regularly clear out slow-moving inventory (to avoid overlapping storage fees across multiple warehouses). Use inventory management tools (such as InventoryLab and Sellics) to simultaneously monitor inventory across multiple warehouses and set unified replenishment reminders.
IV. Advanced Strategy: Dynamically Switching from a “Single Warehouse” to a Multi-Warehouse and Hybrid Layout
A mature FBA inventory layout isn’t a “black or white” model. Instead, it’s dynamically adjusted based on the product lifecycle and market changes, even employing a hybrid model of “single warehouse + multi-warehouse”:
- Switching by “Product Lifecycle”
Introduction Phase (New Products): Stock up in a single warehouse, conduct concentrated market testing, and collect sales data;
Growth Phase (Rapid Sales Growth): Activate a “dual warehouse” layout (e.g., Western + Eastern US) to cover core order areas and improve timeliness;
Maturity Phase (Stability of Hot Products): Expand to multiple warehouses (e.g., Western + Central + Eastern US) to diversify risks and accommodate peak season traffic;
Decline Phase (Decline in Sales): Retreat back to a single warehouse, clear inventory, and reduce storage costs.
- Mixed Layout by Market Type
Core Markets: Multi-warehouse inventory (e.g., three warehouses in the US) to ensure delivery time and customer experience;
Emerging Markets: Single-warehouse inventory (e.g., a US warehouse covering Canada) to control trial-and-error costs;
High-Risk Markets: Multi-warehouse inventory (e.g., separate inventory for each European country) to prevent policy changes in one country from impacting the overall situation.
- Optimize by Replenishment Rhythm
Multi-warehouse “Base Inventory”: Inventory based on regional sales volume to meet daily demand;
Single-warehouse “Backup Inventory”: Reserve 10%-20% of backup inventory at the hub warehouse. When multiple warehouses in a region run low on inventory, Amazon can quickly allocate inventory to fill the gap, balancing delivery time and cost.
V. Pitfalls to Avoid: Common Mistakes in Two Layout Types
Single-Warehouse Pitfall: Blindly relying on “automatic transfers” while ignoring transfer fees and timeliness can lead to “seemingly saving on initial costs, but actually incurring extra transfer fees and losses from stockouts.”
Multi-Warehouse Pitfall: Unsupported “even distribution” (e.g., stocking the same amount of goods in each warehouse) can lead to stockouts in popular areas and overstocking in less popular areas, ultimately increasing costs.
Summary: How to Make Quick Decisions?
If you’re a new seller, testing new products, or selling low-priced products: Prioritize a single warehouse and focus on cost control and data verification.
If you’re an established seller, selling popular products, selling high-priced products/heavy goods, or focusing on core markets: A multi-warehouse strategy is essential to seize timeliness benefits and diversify risks.
If you’re in the growth phase and experiencing significant sales fluctuations: Adopt a hybrid model of “dual warehouses + backup inventory” to balance efficiency and flexibility.
Essentially, FBA inventory layout is a trade-off between “cost for experience, and diversification for security.” Ultimately, it comes down to the core formula of “Profit = (Selling Price – Cost) × Sales Volume.” The ultimate decision-making process hinges on whether the increased sales from multiple warehouses (weighted by time efficiency and reduced negative reviews) offsets the additional costs, and whether the cost savings from a single warehouse offset losses from stockouts and negative reviews.
If you have any international logistics service needs, please contact us by clicking the floating chat icon in the lower right corner or using other contact information in the lower right corner.
